What’s the Best Paint Finish for Your Walls?

Why We Recommend Matte for Walls & Satin for Trim in Historic New England Homes

If you're renovating an older home in New England, you're likely navigating a mix of character-filled details—plaster walls, vintage millwork, original trim, and maybe even some lovingly imperfect surfaces. And while paint color often steals the spotlight, the paint finish you choose can make or break the final result.

In our interior design studio, we take a thoughtful, consistent approach to finishes that respects the home’s age while elevating its livability:Matte for all drywall and plaster walls. Satin for all trim, baseboards, and wall paneling.

This pairing is our go-to for creating timeless interiors that feel warm, elegant, and cohesive—while standing up to everyday life.

Matte Walls: The Best Paint Finish for Plaster & Drywall

Soft. Sophisticated. Historically appropriate.

Matte paint is ideal for historic homes because it offers a velvety, non-reflective finish that complements the natural character of older walls. It absorbs light rather than reflecting it, which softens the look of the space and minimizes imperfections—especially valuable for original plaster or aged drywall that isn't perfectly smooth.

Why we use matte paint on all walls:

• Conceals cracks, patches, and surface irregularities

• Enhances historic charm and authenticity

• Lends a timeless, high-end look with a soft finish

• Reduces glare in rooms with ample natural light

Modern matte paints—like Benjamin Moore's Aura or Farrow & Ball’s estate emulsion—also offer increased durability, making them a beautiful yet practical option for daily living.

Best for: Living rooms, bedrooms, dining rooms, hallways, and any walls where you want an elegant, low-sheen finish.

Satin Trim: The Best Finish for Millwork, Paneling & Baseboards

Durable. Defined. Classic.

Your trim and wall paneling deserve a finish that highlights their craftsmanship and holds up to everyday wear. Satin paint, with its soft sheen and smooth texture, adds just the right amount of contrast against matte walls—subtly drawing attention to architectural details without feeling too glossy.

Why we use satin paint on trim and paneling:

• Easier to clean than flat or matte finishes

• Adds gentle contrast and depth

• Accentuates crown molding, window casings, wainscoting, and doors

• Enhances traditional millwork in New England homes

We also recommend satin for painted built-ins, stair balusters, and cabinetry for a consistent, polished look.

Best for: Trim, baseboards, interior doors, paneling, cabinetry, and built-ins.

Why This Combo Works in Older Homes

Pairing matte walls with satin trim creates a layered, intentional look that highlights the architectural integrity of your home while delivering on function. In homes with character—think wide-plank floors, original fireplaces, plaster ceilings—this combination respects the past while updating the home for modern living.

It also simplifies your decision-making process: two finishes, clearly defined by surface type, that create visual harmony throughout your home.

Final Thoughts: Choosing Paint Finishes for a New England Renovation

If you're investing in a renovation, don’t let the wrong paint finish detract from your hard work. Choosing matte for walls and satin for trim creates a classic, durable foundation that supports both your home’s heritage and your day-to-day life.

Ready to make confident, timeless design decisions for your historic home? We’d love to guide you every step of the way—from paint selections to full-service renovations.Inquire now to start your interior design project.